Already have an account?
Get back to the

The Best Waterproof Eye Pencils for a Bold Look

Courtney BIrtcher
Written by Courtney Birtcher
highly rated waterproof eye pencil

Dare to take a daring plunge into the world of long-lasting beauty with waterproof eyeliner pencils, the unsung heroes of the makeup industry. Surpassing the limitations and smudging woes of traditional eye pencil products, these waterproof variants vow to provide immaculate, smudge-proof lines that enhance and define your eyes, regardless of weather or circumstance. The advent of waterproof technology in cosmetics has incorporated an element of resilience, guaranteeing that your eye makeup remains intact and vibrant from early morning meetings to late-night rendezvous. Delve into the ocean of these innovative products with us as we take you through the best in waterproof eye pencils in 2023, detailing their unique features, benefits, and application secrets to attain that perfect, enduring look.

Us Weekly aims to feature only the best products and services. We update when possible, but deals expire and prices can change.
If you buy something via one of our links, we may earn a commission. Learn more!

Waterproof Eye Pencils: A Buying Guide

Finding the perfect waterproof eye pencil can be a daunting task, given the plethora of options available in the market. However, with a little knowledge and guidance, you can navigate through the products and find a waterproof eye pencil that works best for you. This comprehensive guide is aimed at helping you understand what to look for while buying a waterproof eye pencil. So, let's dive in.


The first and most important attribute of a waterproof eye pencil is its staying power. The whole point of investing in a waterproof eye pencil is to ensure that your makeup remains intact irrespective of sweat, tears, or humidity. Look for a product that promises at least 12-24 hours of stay. Reading reviews and product descriptions, can give you a better understanding of the pencil's longevity.


Another critical feature to consider is the smudge-proof quality of the eye pencil. The best waterproof eye pencil should have a non-transferable formula, meaning it should not smudge or smear throughout the day. The last thing you want is to spend time perfecting your eye makeup, only to have it smudge within a few hours. When shopping, look for terms like "smudge-proof," "smear-resistant," or "non-transferable" in the product description.


Pigmentation refers to how rich and vibrant the color of the eye pencil is. A good waterproof eye pencil should have high pigmentation, so it delivers intense color in a single swipe. This ensures that you don't have to keep applying layers to achieve the desired shade. Some waterproof eye pencils also come in a variety of colors, allowing you to experiment with different looks.


The best waterproof eye pencil should glide smoothly on your eyelid or waterline without tugging or pulling. Look for a formula that is creamy or gel-based as these tend to be more comfortable to apply. Additionally, a thin, precise tip can make the application process easier, especially for creating detailed looks like winged eyeliner or cat eyes.

Skin Compatibility

A great waterproof eye pencil should not only look good but also feel good. It should be ophthalmologist-tested and safe for sensitive eyes and contact lens wearers. If you have sensitive skin, look for a hypoallergenic eye pencil. It's also worth considering a product that is free from harsh chemicals and synthetic fragrances, which can cause skin irritation.

Brand Reputation

Finally, consider the reputation of the brand while purchasing a waterproof eye pencil. Established brands usually offer higher quality, reliable products. They also often have better customer service and return policies, which can be helpful if you experience any issues with your purchase. You can research a brand's reputation by reading customer reviews and ratings online.

Comparing the Top Waterproof Eye Pencils of 2024


OFIR Vegan Waterproof Eye Pencil


  • Lasts all day without fading
  • Maintains initial look throughout the day
  • Excellent full-coverage finish


  • Liner is soft and might break

For those who value both beauty and durability, the OFIR Eye Line Waterproof Eye Pencil is your ultimate companion. Its vegan formulation guarantees a cruelty-free product that doesn't skimp on quality. The pencil's creamy gel texture ensures a seamless application process, gliding effortlessly over your lids to deliver a full-coverage finish. You'll marvel at its waterproof feature that guarantees impeccable eyeliner that lasts all day, rain or shine. No more worrying about smudged or smeared makeup with this waterproof eye pencil, even during the most hectic of days. Touted as the best overall eyeliner for a maintained look, this pencil's staying power is genuinely unparalleled. Its pigmentation remains vibrant and unblemished throughout the day, allowing you a worry-free experience from morning to night. This waterproof eye pencil doesn't just promise longevity; it delivers. Its high-end quality also ensures that it's gentle on the eyes, causing no irritation or discomfort. Whether you're crafting a delicate daytime look or a dramatic evening smoky eye, this waterproof eye pencil's versatility and durability will exceed your expectations. In essence, it's beauty and resilience combined in one easy-to-use product.


Revlon ColorStay Pencil Eyeliner


  • Easy to apply
  • Long-lasting wear
  • Smudge-proof formula


  • Sharpener can break the eyeliner tip

Revlon's Pencil Eyeliner is a knockout product for those in search of a long-lasting, smudge-proof solution to their eye makeup needs. This waterproof eye pencil is not only durable, but also guarantees a smooth application every time. Its built-in sharpener ensures precision and convenience, while the ultra-fine tip allows for accurate and detailed lining. Available in multiple colors, this pencil provides intense color that stays put, regardless of the weather or your daily activities. What sets this eye pencil apart is its resistance to smudging, making it an excellent choice for those with busy lifestyles or for occasions when you need your makeup to last. Moreover, this product makes for a fantastic gift for all makeup lovers and is a perfect addition to any stocking stuffers. It's not just an eye pencil; it's a reliable beauty tool that delivers professional-grade results right at your fingertips. For a truly transformative eye makeup experience, this pick is a must-try.


Maybelline Unstoppable Waterproof Eyeliner


  • Excellent color payoff
  • Long-lasting wear
  • No need for sharpening


  • Smears when used for tightlining

Transform your eye makeup game with Maybelline Unstoppable Waterproof Mechanical Black Eyeliner. This waterproof eye pencil is a cosmetic revelation, providing an extraordinary color payoff that intensifies your look. Its deep, bold black shade sets a dramatic tone that's guaranteed to turn heads. The richness of its color, combined with its waterproof performance, ensures that your eyes remain the star of the show, even in the face of tears or perspiration. What sets this pencil apart is its no-sharpener-required design. This feature is a boon, saving you from the hassle of constant sharpening and potential mess. The mechanical roll-up design ensures you're always ready to define your eyes, making it an essential addition to both your daily and travel makeup kit. The smooth application and long-lasting performance further solidify its position as a must-have in your beauty arsenal. This waterproof eye pencil promises not just convenience, but also a stunning and smudge-free look that lasts all day. Truly, this mechanical eyeliner is a revolution in eye cosmetics – a product that has firmly established itself as a staple for eye makeup enthusiasts.


L’Oréal Paris Infallible Waterproof Eyeliner


  • Highly long-lasting and smudge-proof
  • Easy and smooth application
  • Intense and pigmented color


  • Difficult to remove

The L’Oréal Paris Cosmetics Infallible Pro-Last Waterproof Pencil Eyeliner promises a game-changing experience for eyeliner enthusiasts. With its glide-on application, this waterproof eye pencil offers a rich, smudge-resistant color that promises to last throughout the day. This eyeliner stands out for its striking color variety, allowing you to effortlessly switch up your look as desired. The product is praised for its longevity and resilience, making it perfect for those with busy schedules or those who live in wet climates. It is also smudge-proof, ensuring your look stays fresh and intact from morning to night. This pick is the ultimate go-to product when it comes to achieving sharp, defined eyes. It's like having a professional makeup artist in your makeup bag! 


Laura Geller NY INKcredible Gel Eyeliner


  • Lasts all day
  • Easy to apply
  • Includes built-in sharpener


  • Eyeliner may fall out from pencil after frequent use

LAURA GELLER NEW YORK INKcredible Gel Eyeliner is the perfect companion for those desiring long-lasting, waterproof makeup. This waterproof eye pencil boasts an unbeatable blend of endurance and precision, leaving your eyes looking stunning all day, come rain or shine. This eye pencil doesn't just make a promise of being waterproof; it lives up to it. Whether you're caught in a downpour, sweating at the gym, or simply have a long day ahead, you can rest assured that this eyeliner won't smudge or fade. What sets this waterproof eye pencil apart is its built-in sharpener that ensures precision with every application. The rich gel texture glides on smoothly, delivering a bold, intense line that won't budge. More than just an eyeliner, it's a beauty tool that enables you to create a variety of eye looks, from a simple tight line to a dramatic cat eye. This product is truly incredible and an absolute must-have for anyone seeking a reliable, waterproof eye pencil. Its powerful formula, combined with the convenience of an integrated sharpener, makes this product a truly worthy addition to your makeup routine.

People Also Ask

  • Q: How do I apply a waterproof eye pencil?

    A:To apply a waterproof eye pencil, use the pencil to draw a line as close as possible to your lash line. Start from the inner corner of your eye and move towards the outer corner. You can create a thin or thick line based on your preference.

  • Q: Can I sharpen a waterproof eye pencil?

    A:Yes, you can sharpen your waterproof eye pencil. Use a cosmetic sharpener and gently turn the pencil in the sharpener until you achieve the desired point.

  • Q: How can I remove waterproof eye pencil?

    A:Waterproof eye pencil can be removed with a makeup remover that is specifically designed to remove waterproof makeup. Apply the remover to a cotton pad and gently wipe it across the eye area until all makeup is removed.

  • Q: What should I do if the waterproof eye pencil irritates my eyes?

    A:If the waterproof eye pencil irritates your eyes, stop using it immediately. Consult a healthcare professional or a dermatologist if the irritation continues.

  • Q: Can I use waterproof a eye pencil on my waterline?

    A:Many waterproof eye pencils are safe to use on the waterline. However, always check the product packaging or the manufacturer's instructions to ensure it is safe for waterline application.

  • Q: How can I prevent an waterproof eye pencil from breaking?

    A:To prevent your waterproof eye pencil from breaking, avoid dropping it or applying too much pressure when using it. Also, ensure it is never over-sharpened, as a very fine point can easily break.

  • Q: How long does a waterproof eye pencil last once applied?

    A:A waterproof eye pencil typically lasts all day once applied due to its smudge-proof and water-resistant features. However, the duration can vary depending on the specific product and individual skin type.

  • Q: Do all waterproof eye pencils come in the same color?

    A:No, waterproof eye pencils come in a variety of colors. While black and brown are the most common, they also come in other colors like blue, green, and white for different looks and preferences.

Why trust Us

At Us Weekly, we aim to inform readers to make smart purchasing decisions, saving you both time and money. Our editors are obsessed with finding products in a variety of categories from fashion and beauty, to home and fitness.

We try various products, so we can recommend our favorites, and we also summarize feedback and data from other customers. Data, like product reviews and ratings, helps us recommend the best product choices for individual price points and needs.

On top of that, we highlight unique product features for special use cases, ingredients preferences, and more. We strive to make sure you are discovering new products that can make your life easier, while keeping you up to date with the best product choices for types of items you already know and love.

Courtney BIrtcher

By Courtney Birtcher

Courtney is a lifestyle commerce writer specializing in health, fitness, fashion, and beauty topics on Us Weekly; she currently writes similar review and how-to articles for Blissmark and The Supplement Institute in addition to being a social media influencer on Instagram and content creator on TikTok. In her spare time, she enjoys reading, adventuring with her three dogs through her home state of Ohio, and spending time at her gym.

Got a Tip form close button
Got a tip for US?
We're All Ears for Celebrity Buzz!