What makes the MZOO Eye Mask our top pick? It has soft, foam-filled contoured eye cups that don’t put pressure on the eyes. We love that this mask also effectively blocks all light and has a strap with a slide adjuster to help you get the right fit.

While we didn’t experience this, a few customers noted that the foam created pressure if they slept on their side. The mask is also hand wash only and takes a long time to dry.

For the most budget-friendly option that still helps you achieve a great night’s sleep, opt for the LKY Digital Blackout 3D eye mask. This mask comes in a pack of three, and each one has a strap with a slide adjuster. We like that the foam contouring around the eyes prevents eye pressure and blocks out all light.

While the slide adjuster is small, it may cause discomfort on the side of the head for side sleepers. This mask also has a slightly bulky feel and it’s hand wash only. On the plus side, having three masks in a pack means you can change between them and wear a different mask while one of yours is drying.

If you want the experience of blackout curtains without having to pay for them, try the Greenleaf Elysium Silk Sleep Mask. This plush, soft mask has gentle, thick wrap-around straps that stay in place and dampen sound. We also like that it has padding around the eyes to prevent eye pressure and a deep V cut around the nose, which keeps the mask flush to the face to block out light.

Note that this product is hand-wash only and expensive — though if you think of it as a replacement for blackout curtains, it’s a win!

What the Fishers Finery mask does well: This 100% silk mask can help reduce skin irritation and frizz, and the scrunchy strap makes it easy to put on and remove. We love that the soft, contoured foam eye cups alleviate eye pressure. A bonus: While hand washing is preferred for silk, you can machine wash this mask in a mesh bag on a delicate cycle and dry it on low heat.

On the other hand, the foam eye cups may add pressure on the side of the face for side sleepers. In addition, the strap is not adjustable, though Fishers Finery also sells a silk mask with an adjustable strap.

Contoured eye cups aren’t always a guarantee that an eye mask will block out all light, because the fit might be wrong. Fortunately, the Manta 100% Light Blocking Sleep Mask has an adjustable strap and adjustable eye cups, so you can create the perfect fit.

However, the adjusting process can get tedious and the heavily contoured cups may feel bulky, especially for side sleepers. This mask isn’t ideal for stomach sleepers, either.

If you struggle with sleep masks because they always slide off during the night, consider the Mavogel Cotton Light-Blocking Mask. It has a long elastic strap with slide adjusters to help you keep the mask snug, and the black sponge inside the soft cotton blocks all light, including light that comes in around the nose.

The downsides? This mask is hand wash only, and the adjusting clasp can feel uncomfortable for side sleepers. A few buyers also noticed that the elastic band wore down quickly.

Looking for a luxurious experience on a budget? Try the Alaska Bear Natural Silk Sleep Mask. It has a silk exterior and foam contouring around the eyes to alleviate pressure. We also like that the soft nose wire keeps the mask in place, and that the silk isn’t too slippery.

What could be improved: We noticed that some light can seep in at the bottom of the eyes around the nose area. Plus, the tension at the back of the strap can get uncomfortable. Note that this mask is hand wash only.

One of the best reasons not to buy a silk mask is that you may be able to machine wash it. Indeed, the Simply Organic Bamboo Sleep Mask is incredibly soft but can still be washed on a cold, gentle cycle and laid flat to dry. Simply Organic also offers a 30-night trial, so you can return the mask if it doesn’t work for you.

The downsides? If you return the mask, you must pay return shipping. The scrunchy strap is also not adjustable, though you may prefer this style if you want to protect your hair.

What we love about the Ostrichpillow Blackout Sleep Eye Mask: Though contoured eye cups can get uncomfortable for side sleepers, the foam cups in the Ostrichpillow mask are flexible and gentle enough so you can sleep on your side without issue. We love that the six layers of fabric block all light, and that the mask can be machine washed on a gentle cycle.

However, this product is expensive and won’t hold up as long if you machine wash it. The mask is also uncomfortable to wear with headphones.

Of all the masks we tried, the Drowsy Silk Sleep Eye Mask creates the most luxurious sleep experience. It has an adjustable, thick wraparound head strap that keeps the mask in place without feeling uncomfortable. The straps also dampen sound significantly, and the padded eye area blocks out all light.

Bear in mind that this is our most expensive recommendation. The design may also feel bulky, especially if you sleep on your side, though we didn’t find it uncomfortable.

Pima cotton, an extremely soft, silky and high-quality cotton, is an excellent alternative to silk if you prioritize comfort and organic materials. The Lunya Organic Pima Sleep Mask utilizes pima cotton well — this mask is incredibly soft and comfortable, and the thick padding blocks out all light while alleviating eye pressure. We also like that the thick straps muffle sound.

On the other hand, this mask can feel bulky. It’s also one of our more expensive recommendations.

Looking for a budget-friendly, hypoallergenic sleep mask that still blocks out light? If so, try the Cottonique Hypoallergenic Eye Mask. It has an adjustable, thick velcro strap that alleviates pressure around the head, and you can machine wash it on a gentle cycle. We also like that the material is 100% organic cotton.

However, the straps may be uncomfortable if you sleep on your back because the extra material rests at the back of the head. The loop on the side can also cause discomfort, and the mask may lose its shape over time, especially if you machine wash it.

Hoping to wear your headphones and your sleep mask at the same time? If so, consider an all-in-one product like the LC-dolida Sleep Headphones and 3D Sleep Mask. This futuristic mask contains wireless bluetooth headphones and connects to your phone. We love that the control panel is on the front of the mask — a smart placement for side and back sleepers.

Of course, this mask can’t be tossed in the washing machine and it may be difficult to clean. It can also cause some discomfort around the ears at first.

If you have lash extensions, we recommend the Slip Silk Contoured Sleep Mask. It has large, contoured eye cups that shouldn’t push into your lashes and a scrunchy band that is soft on hair. The silk material also reduces the chances of bed head or skin creases.

However, this mask is expensive and requires hand washing. The scrunchy strap is also not adjustable.

You might not know you needed it, but a naturally scented, weighted sleep mask may be a game changer for your nighttime routine. The Yana Aromatherapy Weighted Mask has a soft exterior layer that you can machine wash and an interior, 100% cotton pouch filled with lavender and flaxseed. Place the inner pouch in the microwave for 30 seconds if you want heat therapy, or chill it in the freezer for at least half an hour if you prefer cooling therapy. Overall, this mask is excellent for headaches and eye pain.

The downsides: This mask is expensive, and you may find it tedious to take the inner pouch out every time you want to heat or cool it. The product may also be uncomfortable for side sleepers.

Struggling with eye pain? Consider a compressive sleep mask like the IMAK Compression Pain Relieving Mask. It has a contoured eye shape to alleviate eye pressure, and the weight can help open the sinuses and soothe sore eyes. We like that you can place this mask in the freezer for a cooling effect.

While this mask does a great job of blocking out light, it isn’t 100% effective. The strap is also not adjustable and the mask requires hand washing.

What we like about the Loftie Silky Sleep Mask: The non-silk material is slippery, soft and great on skin and hair. The material also stays cool throughout the night, and the hidden eye cups relieve eye pressure.

On the other hand, we noticed that a little light came through around the nose area. The scrunchy strap is also not adjustable, though it is comfortable and easy to put on or remove.