The Best Eyelash Curlers for Straight, Short or Long Lashes

If you’re looking for an all-around great eyelash curler with grippy spring handles, a long-lasting design, comfortable silicone pads and a little pizzazz, you’ll love the Lash Star Stardust Eyelash Curler. I found that this curler delivered results again and again, and I was never afraid that it would pull out my lashes or pinch. It was also easy to walk the curler up my lashes and curl them at a slightly higher point to create more of a curve.

What you might not like: This curler is expensive, and the jewel encrusted handle may not appeal to you. You may also prefer a firmer silicone pad to prevent a hard crimp, though I found this added comfort.

What makes the Kevyn Aucoin Beauty Eyelash Curler such a great all-around pick? It has a long curve and a wide opening, both of which can accommodate a variety of eye shapes and lash types. Plus, the classic, stainless steel design makes it durable. I found that this curler creates beautiful, fanned-out lashes. I also love that you can use it before and after mascara, and you can flip it upside down and use it on your bottom lashes.

The downsides? This is an expensive curler, and without careful placement you may accidentally pinch your lids. There is also a tiny space between the silicone and the curler on either side that can trap lashes.

If you like the idea of a comfortable, non-pinching curler like the Lash Star Stardust Eyelash Curler but prefer scissor handles, try the Supreme Lash Curler. The stainless steel metal is plated in 24-karat gold, which is naturally hypoallergenic. Plus, the curler has that same squishy silicone, which helped me crimp my lashes in less time.

However, you may prefer a firmer silicone pad to create a milder crimp. This curler is also expensive.

Not all good lash curlers cost over $25! Meet the Wet n Wild High On Lash Eyelash Curler, a budget-friendly pick that delivers lifted, fanned-out lashes. It has a sturdy feel which helps create a secure, firm grip while you are curling your lashes. Overall, buyers note that this curler makes a long-lasting curl when used correctly.

However, this curler doesn’t work well for every eye shape, as it has a pronounced curve. A few buyers also found that it broke within the first year of use. Note that this curler doesn’t come with an extra silicone pad.

While metal eyelash curlers have a luxurious feel, they aren’t always the easiest or most comfortable to use. If you’d prefer to try a hybrid curler (which has both plastic and metal), we recommend the Kaasage Eyelash Curler. It has grippy handles that don’t get stuck in any one position, and the overall design is sturdy and built for longevity. Best of all, this product comes with tweezers, a small storage bag and five replacement silicone pads.

The downsides? The actual curler isn’t ideal for almond-shaped eyes and eyes that don’t have a pronounced curve. In addition, the metal mechanism beneath the curler can pinch the under eye skin if you’re not careful. A few customers also found that the crimp was too extreme, and the curler damaged their eyelashes.

Heated eyelash curlers get a bad rap for causing lash damage, but the Lash Star Heated Lash Curler will change your mind. I found that it was easier to use than many traditional curlers and less anxiety-inducing — I wasn’t going to accidentally rip out my lashes! Plus, it gave my lashes an impressive lift that lasted all day long. I loved that I could choose between several different heat levels (75 degrees celsius, or 167 degrees Fahrenheit, was enough to create a substantial curl on my lashes). Overall, this is the curler I return to the most, and it hasn’t caused any adverse effects on my lashes.

However, there is a learning curve. It’s easy to create an unnatural curl with a heated curler, as the lash ends tend to stick straight up. This product is also expensive, and the cap often pops off when I store the curler in my makeup bag.

Love the idea of a heated eyelash curler but don’t want to spend more than $20? If so, consider the TOUCHBeauty Professional Heated Eyelash Curler. It works like a manual lash curler in that you still have to squeeze it at the base of your lashes to achieve a curl, but gently-heated, soft silicone pads enhance the curl.

While the curling process takes the same amount of time as a traditional curler (perhaps more, as you have to wait for the curler to heat up), the effect may be longer-lasting because of the heat. Other features you may not like: This curler requires AA batteries, and some buyers received products that stopped working after just a few uses.

Mechanical eyelash curlers can damage lash extensions (like those worn by Sabrina Carpenter), but a heated curler can give them an impressive lift without causing issues. The Chella Deluxe Heated Eyelash Curler is a top pick for lash extensions because it uses gentle heat to help you brush the lashes into an upward sweep. It also has a rechargeable battery (no AAs here!) and the handle is easy to maneuver.

On the other hand, it takes time to use this heated curler because you have to wait for it to heat and it can take several rounds to fully curl your lashes. It’s also a pricey pick.

If you have sensitive eyes and need to be careful about the metal you use near your skin, try the Tweezerman Classic Eyelash Curler. This hypoallergenic curler contains only stainless steel and silicone, so it’s built to prevent irritation and last a long time. The large curve of the curler can also accommodate a wide variety of eye shapes, and the silicone is medium firm.

However, this curler can leave a harsh crimp in your lashes if you aren’t careful with your technique. A few customers also received faulty products. Others note that the design has changed in recent years and isn’t quite as good as the original.

A spring handle lash curler is a great pick if you like the feel of spring-handled scissors. It can help make for a more comfortable curling process, and the grippy handles mean you won’t slip and accidentally rip your lashes. Best of all, this curler comes with a sample-sized bottle of Tarte’s Lights, Camera, Lashes Mascara.

The downsides? This curler and mascara duo is on the pricey side, and a few customers have received products with faulty springs. They can also be harsh on lash extensions (though manual curlers in general are not ideal for lash extensions).

If you’re looking for an elegant curler that can create the illusion of long, fanned-out lashes, check out the Surratt Relevee Lash Curler. It has a wide curler opening and the curve is less pronounced than other products, so it can accommodate almond-shaped eyes and short or sparse lashes. All in all, this is a high-quality curler that is worth the splurge.

What you might not like: A few customers received used products when purchasing off Amazon. It’s also expensive.

It’s not easy finding a curler that can accommodate short or sparse lashes, but the Shiseido can do both. This award-winning curler has an “edge-free” design, meaning either side of the curler opening is sealed to prevent pinching. It also has a less-pronounced curve than other products, so it can grab lashes close to the lid. Overall, this curler creates an all-day curl for even the toughest lashes.

However, this product is pricey, and a few customers have accidentally ripped or damaged their lashes when using it. Others note that the curl can look unnatural depending on how firm you are in your grip when crimping the lashes.

On the hunt for a less-expensive alternative to the Shiseido Eyelash Curler? If so, consider the Brilliant Beauty Eyelash Curler. The modest curve on the curl opening helps you grab onto lashes at the base, and the firm silicone pad prevents a harsh crimp from forming as you curl. Another bonus: The curler comes with a small carrying bag and two replacement pads.

However, the handles on this curler are a bit short, which can make it slightly difficult to use. A few buyers also found that the edges of the curler could pull out their eyelashes if they weren’t careful with their placement. Plus, the silicone may be too firm depending on your preference.

Most eyelash curlers can’t accommodate almond-shaped eyes, which have a wider, flat-top lid and a short distance between the top and bottom lid. In contrast, the Tweezerman Curl 38 Eyelash Curler is designed specifically for almond-shaped eyes. This curler has a wide and flat curved top bar along with a narrower opening so you can precisely squeeze all lashes. In addition, the wider distance between the scissor handles gives you more control. This curler comes with three silicone replacement pads.

What can be improved: A few customers have had the lash curler break on them after several years of use, which caused them to accidentally rip out their lashes. Also, Tweezerman doesn’t sell separate replacement pads specific to the Curl 38 Curler.

If you’re just entering the world of lash curlers, the Hourglass Lash Curler is an excellent place to start. It has a sturdy feel and wide handles, which gives you a sense of control. The curler also has a soft, squishy silicone pad which is easier to use than a firm pad and less likely to cause pinching. Plus, the curved bar is wide enough to capture all the lashes at once (rather than having to curl your lashes in sections).

The downsides: This lash curler has a broad and wide curve that may not accommodate all eye shapes. Soft silicone pads also wear out more quickly than firm ones.

Looking for a simple, cost-effective lash curler that gets the job done? If so, check out the AmazonBasics Eyelash Curler. It has a lightweight feel and a smooth mechanical design that doesn’t stick in one position. It also has a thick silicone pad that lasts longer than most.

On the other hand, some buyers have reported that the lightweight design actually makes the lash curler feel flimsy. It also doesn’t come with any replacement pads, though the pad is a standard size and other brand’s replacement pads fit in this curler. Users with wide, fanned-out lashes may find that this curler pinches the lashes in the outer corners.

Some lash curlers can create an unnatural crimp, curve, or straight-up lashes, but not the Shu Uemura Iconic Lash Curler! It creates fanned-out, fluttery-looking lashes thanks to a wide opening and a subtle curve in the metal bar. The silicone pad is also medium firm, so it is squishy enough to prevent pinching or pulling but firm enough to create a dramatic curl.

However, some buyers have noticed that the most recent model of the Shu Uemura Curler is not the same as older models. In addition, a few customers have found that the curl doesn’t last all day.