Already have an account?
Get back to the

Which New Idol Judge Has the Most to Offer?


When American Idol premieres its 10th season on January 19, all eyes will be on new judges Steven Tyler and Jennifer Lopez, and the pair tell their nerves have hit fever pitch.

Seasoned Aerosmith vet Tyler calls the judging process "excruciating."

"These [contestants] have it so much harder [than I did as a singer]. They haven't had the good graces to play clubs and get beaten down that way," Tyler told reporters at Tuesday's Television Critics Association panel. "So they have their mom and dad telling them they're great, and they feel entitled because they watch the show. They gotta come up and really give it up, and it's just excruciating. It's been hard for me."

But once the talent does get whittled down, Lopez says fans should expect some showstopper performances.

Related: PHOTOS: Amazing Idol makeovers

"For me there are standout moments I have not seen in 10 years [on Idol]," the singer says. "There were some performances in particular where I was just like 'what!?' We're in a place where everyone is so good it's hard to send them home."

Ahead of American Idol's January 19 premiere, watch a sneak peek of the pair's critiques and tell Us: Which new judge has the most to offer?

By Allison Corneau for For more Channel Surfing, click here.

Which new Idol judge has the most to offer?

Which new Idol judge has the most to offer?

Jennifer Lopez
Steven Tyler
665 Total Votes

In this article

Got a Tip form close button
Got a tip for US?
We're All Ears for Celebrity Buzz!