Already have an account?
Get back to the

‘This Is Us’ Fans Are Still Puzzled by One Scene From the Latest Episode — and It’s Related to Jack’s Death

Toby or not Toby. The lovable and doting Toby (Chris Sullivan) has been a favorite of This Is Us fans from the start, as he has wooed Kate (Chrissy Metz) with no shortage of grand romantic gestures, but it seems as though a handful of viewers may be turning on the poor guy. When Kate finally opened up to Toby in the latest episode about the tragic death of her father, Jack (Milo Ventimiglia), fans had a lot to say about the fact that Toby had pressured her about the details.

Related: 10 Most Devastating TV Deaths of 2016

The February 14 episode included some tension between the two lovebirds as their engagement seemed to hit a snag. Toby asked Kate to open up to him about her dad’s death, insisting that they needed to get to know each other better on a deeper level. When Kate couldn’t speak about the traumatic loss, Toby was not having it.

Related: Milo Ventimiglia’s Hotness Evolution

Toby then told Kate that they may need to slow down on plans for their engagement, saying, “I just think we should do it when we’re ready. I just think the woman I marry should be able to talk to me about everything …” This development left fans wondering if it was inappropriate for Toby to expect Kate to divulge so much about her painful past.

Chrissy Metz and Chris Sullivan
Chrissy Metz and Chris Sullivan as Kate and Toby on ‘This Is Us.’ Ron Batzdorff/NBC/NBCU Photo Bank via Getty Images

Later, during the March 7 episode, Kate decided to begin spilling to Toby about the trauma. She cried and confessed, “If we’re gonna start a life together in L.A., then there is something that I need to tell you. You remember when I told you I couldn’t talk about my dad’s death? Well, that’s because it’s my fault. I’m the reason that he’s dead.” Aside from shocking viewers everywhere, this confession made it abundantly clear why Kate wasn’t ready to talk about Jack’s death. It also appears to have led some fans to hop off the #TeamToby bandwagon, at least temporarily.

Related: 15 Best TV Moms!

Check out what fans have been saying on Twitter about Toby pushing Kate to talk about Jack.

Tell Us: Do you think Toby pressured Kate to revisit her past?

This Is Us‘ season 1 finale airs on NBC Tuesday, March 14, at 9 p.m. ET. 

In this article

Got a Tip form close button
Got a tip for US?
We're All Ears for Celebrity Buzz!