Already have an account?
Get back to the

Peter Weber’s Former ‘Bachelor’ Contestants Are Seeing a ‘Completely Different Side’ of Him After the Show (Exclusive)

Will the real Peter please stand up? Peter Weber is showing his true colors after completing his turn as the Bachelor.

Related: Madison Prewett's Post-‘Bachelor’ Revelations

“The girls from Peter’s season are seeing a completely different side of Peter now from who they knew on the show,” a source tells Us Weekly exclusively. “He’s much more laid-back, relaxed and chill. On the show, he was guarded and seemed to be putting on a front.”

Peter Weber Bachelor Exes Are Seeing Different Side of Him After Show
Peter Weber ABC/John Fleenor

Kelley Flanagan, for one, is happy about Weber’s personality swap. “During the show, Kelley noticed Peter was different from what she had remembered when they first met in real life,” the insider reveals. “Now he’s back to the person she first knew and that’s why she is hanging out with him again.”

Weber and Flanagan, both 28, coincidentally met at a hotel before season 24 of The Bachelor began filming. The two hit it off, but he sent her home during the show.

Related: Everything We Learned From Peter’s Post-‘Bachelor’ Interviews

The pair reconnected in Chicago in March. They are quarantining together in the Illinois city amid the coronavirus pandemic.

Weber got engaged to Hannah Ann Sluss at the end of season 24 but called it quits on their relationship because of his lingering feelings for other women. He attempted to rekindle his romance with Madison Prewett during the live finale in March, but they later decided not to get back together.

Related: Peter Weber and Kelley Flanagan: Everything We Know

The pilot’s exes — including Prewett, 24, Kelsey Weier, Tammy Ly, Mykenna Dorn, Kiarra Norman and Deandra Kanuthrew shade at him in a sassy TikTok video on Sunday, April 19. After their post, which was set to Mahogany LOX’s “Take Your Man,” the foster parent recruiter replied to a fan who asked why Flanagan wasn’t included. “[She’s] with our ex lol,” she wrote, later claiming her comment was nothing more than a joke.

Prewett admitted earlier this week that she was “hurt and thrown off” by Weber’s reunion with the attorney. “I told him kind of what I’m saying,” she recalled during the Tuesday, April 21, episode of the “Off the Vine” podcast. “‘What I’m confused about, Peter, is two days ago you were telling me how much you loved me and wanted to get back together and now you’re with the one person that was my best friend.’”

Weber then clapped back at Prewett in the comments section of a fan page: “You’d think you’d have a little more respect for this situation given we both know there’s more to the story…”

Given the constantly evolving nature of COVID-19, Us Weekly wants our readers to have access to the most accurate resources. For the most up-to-date coronavirus information, guidance and support, consult the CDC, WHO and information from local public health officials. If you’re experiencing coronavirus symptoms, call your primary care provider for medical advice.

In this article

Got a Tip form close button
Got a tip for US?
We're All Ears for Celebrity Buzz!